Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

The Wages of Nihilism


Today's news is sad but not surprising. It seems that meaningless violence is the hallmark of our generation's nihilism:


"The ideal young revolutionary of our generation is like an uncaged animal that unleashes blind lust or fury at anything that nears it. What other kind of revolutionary could we expect in a world with nothing worth believing in? It is only the insightful revolutionaries who truly identify... the oppressor within themselves, in their own unrestrained passions. What else to do but turn that limitless fury in on itself? So they unleash all fury on their own angry selves, often killing a schoolyard full of random classmates with them, creating a horror so beautiful and rebellious that the rest of us can only watch with awe and envy. The school shooter is not an isolated phenomenon, he is the final product of the Revolution."

Continue reading "Generation X and the Revolution"

Wednesday, December 27, 2006

The Internet and Identity (Dishonesty in blogging)

With all the fuss these days about personal information on the internet, it is interesting to reflect on the "internet self" many of us create for friends or strangers to see. It seems all this self-expression thrown out into the voyeuristic world of the web, often serves more to hide one's self than reveal. Here is a piece of my journal from a few months back:


It is odd to realize, now that I have my website for publishing thoughts I don't write nearly as much as I did before. Each thing I write is analyzed as it is written: How would this fit on my web page? I seem to have lost that freedom of writing without the burden of a potential audience.


My site is personal, but it is not private. While I never cared too much about my privacy, I do care what people think of me. I know people who read it. I want them to continue to think well of me. I want people who visit my site to find it impressive. All the thoughts are mine, but they are a tiny fraction of what I have written in my life. I choose things I think might be interesting or thought-provoking for those who would visit the site.


But isn't it also true that I choose things that might make me look more intelligent, honest, moral, and artistic than I actually am? The things I keep out of the internet version of myself is the lazy, hedonistic, petty, contradictory, and selfish. The digital "Jonathan Davis" contained in Google, Blogger, and MySpace is, I fear, quite different from the man my wife knows. It is perhaps a fiction similar to the "good doctor" I created my intern year. I think I am growing closer now to the doctor I had hoped to be now. Will the discussions on my blog improve me in a similar way? As a young doctor I think the concealment was a necessary part of the process. But is there any need for concealment on the web other than my sense of pride?


I remind myself that I created my site for discussion of ideas not revelation of character flaws. Private writing and prayer to God is the proper place for confession of sins. Neither I do enough of now. I also doubt the honesty of what I have written now, considering I am likely to eventually post it on my site.

Tuesday, August 15, 2006

Playing the Part

The way doctors are created has always fascinated me. It addition to the mastery of information we expect young physicians to create a role of "doctor" and play it perfectly. I wrote this piece when I was an intern:

It is strange to watch myself from inside myself while at the hospital. It is like watching an actor play a part. The element of acting is thrust upon me. There isn't supposed to be such a thing as a fearful, unknowing doctor so interns first learn the art of taking on a persona cool confidence while panicking inside. "Dr Whittemore, your patient is having trouble breathing." I think, "Oh shit, this man needs someone better than me!" but I never say it. I stay in character. "Get an ABG! I'm on my way," I say calmly. I always arrive smiling and keep smiling no matter what happens. Patients don't like it when doctors show fear. Never let them realize this is the first time you've taken care of this.


In addition to the general requirement that young doctors be actors, I have written a particular flare into my character. He is the gentle, happy healer. I play him quite convincingly. I like this character and so do my patients. The nurses too seem quite charmed. I can keep cool in a crisis and then hug all the nurses and thank them quite naturally. Then I hold the patient's hand until she is laughing and chatting like she doesn't have lines and catheters all over her body. No matter how sleepy, terrified, or angry I become I never break character.


It is strange to watch this character. He must have been stolen from the kindly old "Doc" in some movie or TV show. Overall I like him: somewhat simplistic, but overall good-hearted and humanistic. He may resemble what I might want to become, but he is most definitely not me. He comes out of a script; he is not an expression of who I am today.


I am realizing I act a lot these days. At home I sometimes even play the part of the "good husband," a character not too different from the "good doctor." I suppose I have less acting to do here at home because I really do love and admire this woman. But there are the unavoidable times when love and admiration are not as strong and the best thing to do is stay in character. I know the part well because this character is actually based on myself on my better days. I remember all the lines because I wrote them.


Suddenly this week I am aware of myself as an actor, because I suddenly find myself off stage and out of the heat of the spotlight. Joy is out of town so I have time alone.


I have forgotten how it feels to be alone. The actor is at a loss for who to be with no audience present.


Years ago when I never acted. I was myself. The man you saw or spoke to was more-or-less a true representation of my inner self. There was the freedom to not be good, or wise, or stable. Any desire for goodness, wisdom, or stability naturally required me to examine and improve my mind and character.


Now I find myself having taken on so much responsibility. With responsibilities come expectations. People trust me with their lives when they are ill and far more experienced professionals must obey my orders. These people expect us to behave in a certain way. This job demands acting. I cannot "just be myself" on a bad day. I have to be what those who depend on me need me to be. As an intern the character you must play wears a confidence and knowledge that hides abilities still lacking. As a family practitioner the role also calls for a level of warmth and trustworthiness.


I have become quite an actor out of necessity. I will act out the good doctor in order to become one. The funny thing I have found is that it is much easier to act than to be. So on the days I come home too tired to be a loving husband I still have the strength to play him convincingly. Acting is not wrong –everyone has to occasionally act the part to live up to our responsibilities. However, when you act as much as an intern you replace personal growth with improving your acting. Now to improve myself –my confidence, my goodness, my stability– I just adjust the character I play. No internal changes are needed because the internal never reveals itself.


And then comes a week of solitude. I spend nights of silence and feel suddenly at a loss without a part to play. I used to love to be alone with my thoughts. I used to read and think through my emotions, beliefs, and actions. But I find myself devoid of any emotions, beliefs, or actions at all.


I have been acting so long that I have forgotten how to speak without a script. I have forgotten how to play myself.

-8/26/04

Monday, May 22, 2006

On Altruism

In medicine I have met some incredible humanitarians. I even try to be one myself, which brings up some interesting thoughts on human goodness. It is odd that doing good would inspire anxiety, but I believe it does. I work with some incredibly caring people, but I can't help but wonder if this applies to them too. I wrote this originally in 2001 while in medical school:


Each human role has its inherent fears. The rich fear poverty, the strong fear weakness, the independent fear impotence. But the greatest of fears must be the unspoken fears of the good person. He fears himself.


He fears that he will suddenly be exposed as the opposite of all he does. So he works even harder. His dread that he might someday be caught doing something cruel or selfish makes him into a saint. He is driven to goodness by his phantoms. He wants to see himself as someone else, someone like Mother Teresa, Martin Luther King, or Ghandi, assuming that these people never had that frightening sense of rottenness inside. So the good person becomes good at such a price. He sacrifices himself. He becomes a fiction, a shadow. Ah, but it is a beautiful shadow, something good, something he loves, something worthwhile, a puppet in an imaginary story. And despite all he does for others he dreams at night that they will turn on him and point their fingers saying, "Ha, you are not the good man you seem to be. You are a fraud!" He wakes afraid and tries to comfort himself with better thoughts.


He even tries to still do good while abdicating his claim to the title of goodness. He speaks openly of his flaws to all who praise him as good. But this only makes it worse. They praise him more because he does his good with humility. And so his isolation grows.


The good person is always out of place. Because he always does good he cannot even describe his strange feeling of inadequacy. He is most alone among other good people. “Perhaps something is wrong with me? They cannot possible feel like this.” Of course they are all uncomfortable around him for the same reason, but he doesn't know this.


Such an odd group of good people! These are the ones that really do give all. They change the world. And we admire them, because our own fears drive us to such baser things.